Incantation by Alice Hoffman
April 3, 2007 — Mary Childs
Sometimes we think that persecution of people who were Jewish happened only in Germany under the rule of Hitler and that was an isolated situation. I learned so much more last summer when I visited Berlin, Germany, and took a tour of the Jewish Museum Berlin. There I learned that Jewish people have been persecuted in many parts of the world for over 2000 years.
This book, Incantation, takes us back to the year 1500 during a time in Spain called the Spanish Inquisition. This was a time that many Jewish people were killed, but could avoid death by converting from Judaism to Christianity. These people were called conversos. Some conversos continued to follow their Jewish faith and traditions but in secret. And that’s the background for this story.
Estrella and Catalina are neighbors and friends, and can’t imagine their lives without each other. But then Catalina’s cousin, Andres, comes to live with Catalina’s family and things begin to change between the two friends, along with escalating political events in their town. Public book-burnings of Jewish books, people being killed when their secret religion is discovered, and Catalina’s jealousy of Estrella’s relationship with Andres lead Catalina to do something she can never undo.
I’ve only read one other book by Alice Hoffman–Green Angel–and I really couldn’t get into it. It was dark and depressing, and written in kind of a dream-like way that made it hard to connect with the story. I had the same feeling with this book–that I was reading it through some kind of dream filter, but the subject matter was so intense and I could really feel for Estrella and her struggles.
As in so many books I read for school, the topic of the Spanish Inquisition was another time in history I didn’t know much about. And again, a book opened up another part of our history for me, as well as showing me another time when people were tested by fellow human beings.

