Mystery books and middle school readers is often a tricky combination. Students may come either as individuals interested in checking out a mystery book, or as a whole class where the next genre assignment is to read a mystery. And then the hunt begins.
“Where are your mysteries?” Well, they can be anywhere in the fiction section, depending on the author’s last name. In order to identify them on the shelves, we put a purple “mystery” sticker on the spines so they stand out better. There are the usual series–Nancy Drew, Hardy Boys, and many others, but the series don’t always reflect the highest quality we would like. Then we would like to meet the interest age of the reader–some books are just too juvenile and some too mature, depending on the reader. And some older readers are ready to try out an Agatha Christie or Sherlock Holmes mystery. So the field of possibilities is huge, but what will satisfy the reader is sometimes very small.
So, speaking of Sherlock Holmes, Ingrid in Down the Rabbit Hole is a HUGE fan of Sherlock Holmes! And through some chance happenings, Ingrid finds herself right in the middle of the mystery of who killed Katherine “Cracked-up Katie” Kovac, local one-time celebrity now turned hard luck story. Ingrid deduces that the murder has something to do with the local theater group, Prospect Players, where Ingrid currently has the lead role in the upcoming production of Alice in Wonderland. The more she does to find out who the murderer is, the more it looks like she herself is guilty!
Maybe it was because her character was pretty believable as a middle school girl, but all I could think when she set out to investigate something in the middle of the night or in the middle of the school day was, “What are you thinking, Ingrid!!” If it had been Nancy Drew, I think I would have accepted her actions a little more easily since that’s just how Nancy Drew is–independent and fearless.
Anyway, it’s a pretty good mystery, lots of action and suspense right up to the very end. I see that there is now a 2nd “Echo Falls Mystery” so maybe this will be the start of another series. There were a few problems raised in the first book that never were addressed, so guess we’ll have to stay tuned for the next one.